Showing posts with label Session 7. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Session 7. Show all posts

Group comparison of Session 7

In this session we developed our ideas of where we could incorporate the use of Scenario Planning in our organisations.


Cissy's organization: GLOBAL IELTS Hangzhou branch
Ricky's organization: The insurance company in HK
Milky's organization: The social rescue organization in Japan
Vanice's organization: The power supply companies in HK
Makino's organization: The middle school in mainland
Jack's organization: Confucius Carnival 2012


Comparison Table

Group interactions:

Ricky said: Hi Cissy,Thanks very much for sharing your experience in IELTS. You said it quite write that "no one can guarantee the effect of the change", but still is it a good thing that at least they have done something.

Cissy said: Education pf children is the fist thing for every family, and people pay more attention in education problem in this information era. I think we should do all efforts to reduce the bad effect of changes in education.

Milky said: yes, you are right the basic education is the most important thing I think in the whole learning process.And this will make sense in the following learning procedure, have effect on their learning approaches or learning habit.

Ricky said: Hi Milky,Thanks very much for your sharing about the Scenario planning of Japan, and making a comparison between East Japan earthquake and Wenchuan earchquake.Do you ever experienced such a planning in the restaurant that you worked in before? I am very curious to know about it.

Milky said: Hi,Ricky I do not have some experience that face the earthquake while when I was working in the restaurant, but I have chat with a Japanese who is also a restaurant staff who was just working when the big earthquake happened, maybe the place he was in not so seriously, the consumers just keep calm and sit in the their seat to see whether it will stop in a moment or they should take some steps to face it, at least, they were not felling in panic, without worry or screaming or escape outside.

Cissy said: Hi milky,Thank you for sharing the experience of earthquake.And I think it will be a cherished experience and a forever memory in your life. Japanese has a high quality to manager themselves in daliy live, what's more, they can deal with emegency situation very well. In my opinion, both Chinese and Chinese government have a lot of things to do to deal with natural disasters. What do you think we can do to protect ourselves?

Milky said: Firstly, I think we should keep our mind clear, we should not fell into panic, we should keep calm when some emergency situation happens.secondly, we should have some crisis consciousness in advance, so we have to make prepare and get ready for these thing so that we need not to worry when in some danger situation.

Vanice said: Jack,I understand your situation as I also responsible for the logistic work of seminars and technical forums for staffs. What I always encounter is I have confirmed with all the guest speakers before the event and distribute the rundown to staffs and MC. However, some guests are not able to present due to delay of airplanes or they need to cancel the invitation due to another important meeting etc. We need to change to rundown immediately and arrange other speakers for replacement. Once, we even cancel the seminars as the airport is closed due to heavy snow though we prepare the seminars for more than one month. No matter how well you prepare, there’s always something out of your expectation.

Milky said: your point make sense, have ever talk about this to your manager as a proposal?

Jack said: very nice to receive both your comments.To Vanice, thank you for sharing your own opinion. It's nice to notice that you have the same experience woth me.To Milky, sure, I had told it to my boss.

Cissy said: Hello Jack,I'm glad to know more about the Confucius Carnival 2012 as I want to know more about the organization in Hong Kong. The things I am curious about is what performance your organization give? And how the organization manager the performance team in daily live?

Makino said: Hi Jack, Thank you for sharing the information about the use of Scenario Planning in your organization. I feel very familiar with your organization after the several sessions. I think your organization did well on identifying unanticipated future,preparing the mind for unanticipated future and changing people's mind. You also said that the SP includes 5 points. Are the 5 point the essential stages or just parts of the SP? Does it make sense if the SP lack of 1 or 2 points? ( You don't have to answer my question if you think it has nothing to do with the topic and feel free to give me suggestion, thank you!!!)

Milky said: I think you could make some recommendation to your manager about this situation and he or she will appreciate you.

Ricky said: Hi Vanice, I think the Scenario 1 is difficult to be lowed the price, as once it rises, it is mostly never possible to lowered down. But one way the government can do is to develop an allowance policy to make up for the qualified Hong Kong Residents.

Makino said: Hi Vanice,Thank you for sharing the scenario planning of HongKong companies. You introduced the 6 stages in scenario planing which help me get a deeper understand of it. Do all the organizations who have scenario planning have to go through the 6 stages? What stage of scenario planning do you think the electricity company in HongKong is going on? ( You don't have to answer my question if you think it has nothing to do with the topic and feel free to give me suggestion, thank you!!!)

Milky said: how about imagine some examples that would happen to your organization and you can make some prediction and judgement before the negative things happened.

Makino said: Hi Milky,Thank you for your suggestion. I will think about it. But from my perspective, the scenario planning is not just the preparation for the coming future. I just used the process of scenario planning theory to help explain the use of scenario planning in my school. And in the last part of the theory I have already imagined the prediction.

Makino said: Apart from the concerns that made by the company, I think further consideration needs to be fully made by other groups, such as security department, traffic department, etc.

Vanice said: Hi Ricky,I also think that it will take long time to implement this policy. The Mainland and Hong Kong government may need to establish relevant law regarding who should responsible for the lost when there is accidient etc as there is concern about we cannot find the driver or request he/she to back to HK for investigation after accident.

Ricky said: Hi Vanice,Thanks for your advice. I do think so. But when it comes to the compensation policy, it is quite different between China and Hong Kong, as the quotas vary a lot. Times will be spent to negotiate how to make an agreement, and the way how to compensate, at what requirement...there are a lot of issues to be solved by the company.

Milky said: I want to know, if the policy was been carry out, who will get more benefit, the mainland people or the Hongkong people, only if both of them could get benefit, they will make collaboration to this policy.

Ricky said: Hi Milky,Actually I will not worry about the benefit. It is not a problem for both people in the two places. I would concern about the influence to Hong Kong traffic and Hong Kong insurance policy making. If the policy was carried out too quickly without enough public negotiation and corporation among different apartment (traffic department, immigration department, policy station...), it would be a big disaster and the Hong Kong resident would suffer most, with no good.

Milky said: yes, your worry is reasonable, this is really a contraditory issue, and it will take time to get a balance between the two sides.
However I believe there be a bright future there tomorrow to the relationship between the Hongkong people and mainland people.

Cissy said: As far as I know, the requirements for Chinese to get access to Hong Kong is high. And it's not easy for a public car to have the qualification, not to mention a private car.And the problem will not be so big. Of course, the government should have a fully consideration.




























Session 7 by Cissy

Develop ideas of where you could incorporate the use of Scenario Planning in your organisation. Upload to Group Blog.
I take the GLOBAL IELTS Hangzhou branch as an example. This is an education institution, and mainly focused on youth education. I was an intern there in 2009 summer vacation. In this institution, there was a plan to use computers in the class and provide e-books in the classroom in that time. I will do a scenario planning in this organization.

Scenario planning :
There are 6 steps in scenario planning: find the right issue, locate the driving forces, rate the forces, create scenario, discuss implications and develop indicators.
Find the right issue:
The classes be given in this institution is in traditional and single mode. Children who are participated in this training class felt tired and can not focus themselves in the classes. As a result, the institution wanted to do some changes to adjust the new situation. Computers has been taken into account. Some computers would be a tool in the class and the library. However, no one can guarantee the effect of the change.
Locate the driving forces:
Manger in this institution (Better education mode can make the institution take advantage in the competition).
Children who take classes in this institution
Parents care about their children’s learning
Rate the forces:
Mainly related to the learning effect of children and the benefit of the organization.
Create scenario:
  1. apply computers in the class
  2. add computers in the library and teach children to use it for reading e-books
Discuss the implications:
For scenario 1: The cost of add equipment in the class would be high. At the same time, the institution have to arrange time to train the teachers. Accordingly, teachers must spend more time on operating the computer and do preparations for their classes. And the content rather than the picture, video and audio should be appeal to the children.
For scenario 2: The eyesight of children is mainly concern. Computers may be the big killer of children’s eyesight.
Develop indicators:
For scenario 1: Training class for teachers to use computers correctly should be provided by the institution. Meanwhile, chances for teachers to communicate with each other about computer should be arranged.
For scenario 2: The use time of child should be regulated. In addition to, the institution should add a specific librarian to take charge of computers.
Reference:http://sbinformation.about.com/cs/newseconomy/a/scenario_2.htm

session 7 by Milky

     Session 7 Scenario Planning in a World of Uncertainties     


  • From this video we could get more comprehension about what a scenario planning involves.
  • The scenario planning is a rich and varied domain, and should be     implemented uniquely depending on the context and the objectives    

  What is scenario planning ?

       .

  • Why scenario planning?

              

  •  Scenario planning is a way of simplifying these complex futures by providing the opportunity to ask the what-if questions.




  • And what I want to talk is the situation that what if the natural disaster happened to the organization such like everyone in Japan will concern about the earthquake every time. It is said that there are as much as 20+ earthquake which could be felt by human. And I also experience my first earthquake in japan, I actually felt threatened that I was waked up by the earthquake when I was sleeping in my bed. It is really unforgettable experience. So after several times, I was used to it, I could keep doing my staff without any affect by the naughty quake. If you ask me why, because I feel no danger.






1. there will be accurate forecasting  about it so you could prepare for it in advance.
2.the building there in Japan are with high quality which were under strict examination and monitoring when they were being constructed. 
3. Everyone were equipped with the knowledge of  precaution and self ambulance when trapped in a dangerous dilemma,decrease the loss to the loss.
 4. the social rescue organization are also sufficient prepared and well trained,they are ready to turn out for all the time.




  • What I mentioned above could be a reference to somewhere in our country in which also quake happen regularly like the wenchuan5.12 earthquake in sichuan province,there are nearly 70,000 people died, almost 380,000 people were injured, and about 18,000 people remain missing. I thought if they could do the preparation as well as Japan people, then I think may be there would not be such huge loss both in life and properties.


  • So we could find out how significant the scenario planing is.

  • It is a tool for conservation in an uncertain world.

  • It is the link between future and strategy



Session 7

Develop ideas of where you could incorporate the use of Scenario Planning in your organisation. Upload to Group Blog.

First of all, the scenario planning is about

  1. identifying unanticipated future
  2. a way to prepare the mind for unanticipated future
  3. changing people's mind
And the Scenario planning process include:

  1. identify focal issue
  2. search for driving force
  3. find uncertainties
  4. formulate scenario logic
  5. strategy analysis 
Again and again, I am still using the example that I was the project planner of Confucius Carnival 2012. I hope it will not bored you a lot as it is the internship I had before.

For this job, the main unanticipated future is that --- we cannot assure the performance team will come on time as we had not signed any contract or agreement. They just reply us by phone call. So, if the performance teams suddenly claim that they are not able to come. Then, we can do nothing.
Thus, I will treat it as the main focal issue indeed. The external conditions would be the uncertainties. For example, if there is a traffic jam, then they may not be able to come on time or even not able to come indeed. Besides, maybe they would face the problem of health. The most common problem is that the performers feel sick right before the show and thus they are not able to have any performance even though they come to the carnival.
For the first reason, we can do nothing as the traffic problem is quite serious in Hong Kong especially in Causeway Bay on Saturday. Besides, we can do nothing if the performers feel sick as we cannot force them to keep on perform under such bad condition. Even though they are insisting in performing, they may not have a good show since the illness may affect their performance. 

For this scenario, what we can do is to prepare more functions as a contingency plan so that in case of any accident, we can allocate another performance team to do the "substitution" . But, someone may ask that how will we settle the "substitution" if the origin performer are able to perform? So, it is much better if we (the emcee) can be the contingency plan. Or we can ask the performer to arrive as earlier as possible so as to avoid any case of traffic problem.

For another scenario such as the problem of bad weather, I think it is another uncertainties which is quite common in most of the out-door activities. As the Carnival is held on February which is usually in the winter. Therefore, it has a less chance to have the rainy weather at that moment. Even it has some rain, it must be the small one and it can be solved by preparing lots of umbrella. It is not a big problem since it is not common to have a heavy rain in winter. Moreover, we can look at the weather forecasting in the website of Hong Kong Observatory which can give us a very accurate weather forecasting before the commenced date of the Carnival.







 

Session 7 by Vanice

Develop ideas of where you could incorporate the use of Scenario planning in your organization. Upload to Group Blog.
Scenario Planning Example 1
My workplace has a company library but the facilities are not good enough to cater the user need. As I mention before, this company library is handled by other department before and we have checked the library facilities when we take responsible to handle it. As the library established for long time ago, thus it facility do not cater the need of our users now. And we have decided to improve the library facility and scenario planning can used to analysis different method of library facility improvement.
Scenario Planning
There are six stages in scenario planning which are below:

 


Find the Right Issue:
Library facility cannot cater the user’s need
Locate the Driving Forces:
User would like to view the e learning materials at the library
The new branch would like to take this change to improve the library service quality
Rate the Forces:
Mainly driven by the user as they would have benefit if the library facility is upgraded
Create Scenarios:
Move the library to new place with lan port
Arrange tele-company to install lan port at the library
Discuss Implications:
For scenario 1, staff would be able to view e-materials in the library if we can find a new location with network access. As my company has an outline agreement with logistic company, my branch does not need to use our budgets to arrange staffs to move the library materials. The cost would be much lower than scenario 2.
For scenario 2, staff would also able to view e-materials in the library if we can arrange installation of lan port. However, the process to obtain funding could be time consuming. Management may also expect us to use existing resources to solve the problem instead of granting a new funding.
Develop Indicators:
To make scenario 1 come true, we need to search for a new library location with network access. If a location is decided, we need to present our ideas to the management and convenience them the new location would be a better location for the company library. We also need to arrange staffs to move in and out of the library materials from the old library to the new location.
To make scenario 2 come true, we have to present our ideas about improving the library facility to the management in order to obtain funding to stall lan port. Further, we need to decide where to install the lan port and arrange to tele-company to install it.
______________________________________________________________
Scenario Planning Example 2
Hong Kong has two power supply companies. One supplies electricity to Hong Kong Island where the other supplies electricity to Kowloon and New Territories and they monopolize the Hong Kong power supply market. Hong Kong government consulted the public about their opinions on introduction of new power suppliers on 2005 and finally decided not to introduce new suppliers at the present stage as further investigation is needed.
At the end of 2011, introduction of new power suppliers became a hot issue again as public concerned about the proposed electricity price increase rate.

Scenario Planning
Find the Right Issue:
Introduction of new electricity suppliers
Locate the Driving Forces:
Public concern about the fair market competition
Public concern about the electricity price
Rate the Forces:
Mainly driven by the electricity price.
Create Scenarios:
New suppliers build up power supply plant in Hong Kong
Open grid access to third parties
Discuss Implications:
For scenario 1, the possibilities for this happen would be low for the following reasons:
The cost would be very high in building new power plant and grid networks.
Difficult to find suitable site to built new power plant, such as need to consult with the government and public (process could be very time consuming and need to evaluate the impact to the environment).
The new power suppliers could have total control on the business if they can built up new power supply plant in Hong Kong as they do not need to rely on the power grid of her competitors.
For scenario 2, some of the countries introduce power supply market competition by developing shared power grid. If we have to share our power grid with third parties, some of our company sensitive information may need to share with third parties.
Develop Indicators:
For scenario 1, what we can do is to stay competitive with the new power suppliers by lowering the electricity price such as introduction of smart grid etc.
For scenario 2, we need to overcome the technical problem in opening the grid access and state the responsibility for supply planning with other power suppliers.
Reference: http://sbinformation.about.com/cs/newseconomy/a/scenario_2.htm

Session 7 By Makino

Develop ideas of where you could incorporate the use of scenario planning in your organization.



This animated video can be used to help an audience understand what Scenario Planning is.
From the picture we can easily see that there are 5 stages in the process of scenario planning. So I want to incorporate the use of scenario planning in my organization from the 5 aspects.

Tracking (Outside to inside)
My organization is a common middle school with a traditional pedagogical perceptions in mainland. The outside situation is the schools always be evaluated by the proportion of students entering schools of a higher grade in mainland. So inside the school, principals and teachers pay more attention to students' scores of testbooks based exams. Then the outside situation has changed. The educational official government of my hometown offered a policy that the school must develop students' comprehensive abilities besides studying the textbooks. So it affect the inside school, the organization incorporate the use of scenario planning and made several plans to introduce ICT into school.

Analyzing(Key uncertain factor)
There are several uncertain factors to incorporate the use of scenario planning in my organization. 
Leadership: Less experience to control the ICT implememtation in the whole school and balance the exam and ICT implementation.
Teachers: Change their traditional pedagogy and make full use of ICT in class and be trained to have more information about ICT implementation.
Students: Know the real meaning of using ICT implementation in study instead of just playing on internet and searching information.
These uncertain factors must be forcused on the scenario planning about ICT implementation introduction.

Imagining(Determine vision)
The ICT implementation in education is a trend in scioal development. About this scenario planning, after tracking and analyzing, the organization must get a determine vision. The teachers may adapt quickly and perfectly combine ICT with own pedagogy. Students may make sevearl progress not only in exam but also in many aspects. This scenario planning may also be failed and students and teachers cannot adapt. The organization thought about many situations that may happen in the future. 

Decision(System thinking)
System thinking is very important in scenario planning. The organization must think about how to fund the ICT implementation. The training of teachers is also important. The organization can employ some professional people to train teachers or directly teach students or ask teachers to learn ICT by themselves. The organization also must pay attention to students' performance, lead them to learn with ICT in a right way and find ways to slove some problems such as regress of students' exam scores.

Action(Sustainable development)
This scenario planning about ICT implementation in my organization is difficult to achieve. This plan is fit the whole development of the society, so the organization must keep on no matter how many difficulties it may meet.











Session 7 by Ricky

Scenario Planning Activity

Develop ideas of where you could incorporate the use of Scenario Planning in your organisation. Upload to Group Blog.

Recently, I noticed that there is a governmental public consultation about whether the policy of self-driving to Hong Kong from China will be approved. The result indicated that nearly 80% Hong Kong people had objections about the policy.

Although the result is apparent that the policy is difficult to be approved, however, as an insurance company, once this policy is approved and there are so many self-driving travelers from China, there must be an influence to the company. First is the traffic risk changing, such as the traffic accidents. The company may make a modification to the traffic risk rate, and the extent to the compensation.


http://news.sina.com.hk/news/2/1/1/2566746/1.html